My mother usually plays cards several times a week with a group of women from her church. She called to ask me about a dessert that one of the women had brought that night. She was told that the sugar in the recipe had been replaced with agave syrup and that it was safe for diabetics because it was “natural”. Only problem is that her blood sugar spiked up pretty high. How could this have happened? Aren’t natural sweeteners good for diabetics?
Well, I guess that all depends upon what we are talking about when we say “natural”, “good” and “safe”. People often argue over exact definitions of such words. Natural could mean that the sweetener is produced by nature such as honey. For other people natural means that it is found in nature but needs some method of extraction or processing before it is used. Granulated sugar, palm sugar, beet sugar,corn syrup, sorhgum syrup, maple syrup and agave are found in nature but require some processing before we find them sold in our local grocery store.
Is one type of sweetener good or better than another? Some will argue that the various types of processing are what determines whether or not that particular sweetener is good. Personally, I’ll stay out of that argument for now. The question that I focus on is whether or not a sweetener is “safe” for someone who is diabetic or prediabetic. If someone asks this question what they usually mean is will this spike my blood sugar levels?
Let’s start by looking at regular granulated sugar. Here’s a nutritional label for 1 teaspoon of sugar:
One teaspoon of sugar contains 15 calories. If you look down the list you’ll see one teaspoon of sugar contains 4 grams of carbohydrates. It’s the carbohydrates that affect blood sugar levels. A tablespoon of sugar (3 teaspoons equals 1 tablespoon) would contain 12 grams of carbohydrates.
Now let’s look at some “natural” sugars. Here’s the nutritional info for honey. That’s about as natural as you can get since it doesn’t require any type of processing. You even find honey still sold inside the honeycomb where the bees put it for storage.

One tablespoon of honey contains 64 calories. Total carbohydrates for a tablespoon is 17 grams. So, even though honey is natural, the fact that it contains carbohydrates means that it will affect blood sugar levels. How about maple syrup? That’s pretty natural too.
Here’s the nutritional information for maple syrup:

One tablespoon of maple syrup contains 52 calories. It contains 13 grams of total carbohydrates. Again, that’s what affects blood sugar. How about agave syrup?
Here’s the nutritional label for agave syrup:

Hmmm…..one tablespoon of agave syrup contains 60 calories. Total carbohydrates – 16 grams. So, when you think about it, agave actually contains more carbs/sugars that will affect your blood sugar level than a tablespoon of white sugar. No wonder my mother’s blood sugar levels spiked up after eating the dessert sweetened with this “natural” sweetener.
To answer the question is agave “safe” for diabetics – it is no safer than regular white sugar. Since it contains more carbs when compared to an equal amount of white sugar it could even be considered worse for you. Sugar is a sugar is a sugar. They will all be processed by the body and raise your blood sugar levels. Keep this in mind when buying and using products labeled as “natural” or “diabetic friendly”. Always check the label to see what they consider a serving size and how many carbs it contains.
